Why Did I Use a Descant Horn on Shostakovich Symphony No. 5?

Last Thursday and Friday evenings I played principal horn on Shostakovich Symphony No. 5.  Those who saw the concert noticed that I used a descant horn on the high horn solo at the end of the first movement.  Since then many have asked me why I made that decision.  I could have played the solo on a double horn.  In fact the conductor told me that he liked my solo when I played it on a double horn.  So why did I play the solo on a descant horn?

I used the descant horn for the tiny bit of extra security it provided me with.  For a completely unquantified estimate I could hit all of the notes in the solo with the double horn 97% of the time but with the descant horn I could hit them 99% of the time.  That extra security allowed me to stop worrying about missing notes and to start thinking about the music.  Although I would have no problem playing that solo on a double horn in the future, I would use a descant horn again if one was available.

3 comments to Why Did I Use a Descant Horn on Shostakovich Symphony No. 5?

  • Katie Darling

    Hi,
    I found your website when searching for information on descant horns. I’ve played horn for the last 15 years, but only on a Conn 8D. I recently acquired a Holton descant horn and have no idea how to play it. Are there fingering charts for it out there?

    Thanks!

  • The Bb side of a descant horn uses normal Bb horn fingerings. The high F side of the descant horn uses the F horn fingerings from one octave below. I switch from the Bb side of the horn to the high F side on the Ab above the staff (G and below I stick to the Bb side.) I only use my descant horn on rare occasions, very high passages that need to be played softly or lightly.

  • I’m with you, Derek. The audience doesn’t care how you get it. I use anything that will help get the job done. In my case, it’s a Schmid F/Bb/Eb triple. Descants don’t help you play high, but they give you a couple of per cent better average on the sticky bits up high. And alleluia for that.

    Let me know when your pedagogy book comes out – I would like to buy a copy.

    Keep up the good work and greetings to JQE!

    Jeff Agrell

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>